The Fuss about Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDA)

November 1, 2006 by Bernard Leong  
Filed under Dummy's Guide

Suppose you have a technology company and a technology (which may be a trade secret or in the stage of patenting), you need to meet an investor (whether it’s a venture capitalist or business angel). How do you protect yourself from the investor stealing the idea? A partial solution is the use of a legal document called the Non Disclosure Agreement (NDA). What does this agreement entails? Notice that I use the word partial, because not all investors like NDAs. I will discuss the possible situations where it may be or may not be appropriate to use it and provide a template for those in Singapore who might need it.

In short, A non-disclosure agreement (NDA), is a legal contract between at least two parties which outlines confidential materials or knowledge the parties wish to share with one another for certain purposes, but wish to restrict from generalized use (Source: Wikipedia). In short, it is just a piece of paper to ensure that two parties have agreed not to reveal any information covered by an agreement. If you are selling a particular product that requires protection to deal with the risk of replication by other competitors, this agreement is an essential piece of paper for you. Other terms of the same nature include a confidential disclosure agreement (CDA), confidentiality agreement or secrecy agreement.

In the case of the startups, NDAs are signed when two companies or individuals are considering the creation of a business enterprise, an investment proposal or a partnership agreement. It is required for evaluation of a business relationship as well. NDAs can also mean the following situation: either that both parties are restricted in their use of the materials provided, or they can only restrict a single party. In the case of large companies or even universities and research institutes, NDAs are required to protect privileged information that are disclosed to the employees.

Here are a couple of questions which I often encounter when an entrepreneur asks about the NDA:

  • Where can I find a template of an NDA that details such an agreement?: Basically, the entrepreneur needs to find an example on how to draft an NDA. You can find this URL from Enterprise One where sample NDA templates are provided. Note that it is a sample and you need to modify it to suit your purpose.
  • I hear from my lecturer or from some VCs that they don’t accept NDAs: From the investors’ viewpoint particularly, the venture capitalists, there are two schools of thoughts. Some VCs are alright with signing one and some of them are not. There is no hard and fast rule. So, why is it that some venture capitalists or business angels don’t like to sign an NDA? There are two reasons: first, they don’t want to be tied down because they might encounter an alternate party sharing similar technology or idea like yours and second, the arrogance that since they are receiving a hundred plans per day, what makes your plan that unique that they should sign one?Let me give you my personal experience. In the UK and Europe in general, NDAs are common, and whether you are a startup or an established company, when you need to divulge something regarding technology, a NDA is required. You can imagine my shock when I hear some local investors (but they are trained in the US) telling me that they don’t need that. So, NDA signings can be cultural in another perspective but it is an universally acceptable practice to request the other party to sign an NDA if you feel uncomfortable. You don’t lose brownie points if you ask and they reject signing it. When I do consulting or fundraising for a biotech company who needs to divulge their technology so that I can do a valuation of how much they are worth, I usually ask for a NDA so that my client will trust me to look at their company.
  • Why do I need a NDA?: The answer is obvious. You need to protect your company. Actually, if you listen long enough to successful entrepreneurs, the real strategy is never to protect your technology, but rather, protect your markets, i.e. create barriers of entry for your competitors so that they need a lot of time and effort to roll out an alternative product to match yours.

In practice, it’s good to have one sample NDA with you when you go out and pitch your product. Usually, some people place a few NDA papers in their brief case, so that it comes in handy when meeting investors, business partners and even clients.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Posterous
  • Tumblr
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • Mixx
  • Technorati
  • email

No related posts.


triplepoint-job-board-ad-wanted-developers-500x

Comments

  • Prasoon
    Does anyone have idea about Venture Capital Indian Scenario w.r.t Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDA)??
  • Little Porcupine
    On the other hand,NDA helps seal mouth to mouth talk.But I think patent will still be the best idea to protect your idea. At least instead of you tell someone to keep your secret and they accidentally blurt it to someone whom they never sign any NDA agreement with you. So if the idea land into the wrong hand. They copied your idea. You still have your patent to spam them entirely from using your idea.

    And also given the idea, You visited many company and ask them to sign the NDA. You cant eventually tell who blurted out the trade secret?

    So it could be a problem as well. I think for every product that you invented best that you had a patent attached to it.. That would be the safest way to go. Because,patent doesn't just protect your product but also creating barriers to entry, Which mean if someone else try to copy the same product you can sue them and also you will get all the profit they earn from copying your product back as a consequence.
  • Little Porcupine
    Subsequently, I think there are both pros and cons in obtaining NDA.

    For people with business experience, They probably won't see your project if you have NDA attached to it.

    Because, they cant overlook the overall business nor see the whole business as a potential unless you disclose to them about everything.

    And there are certain business rule/legislation that protect the business as well. If someone wants to invest in your business and was not given full disclosure. It can be known as false misconception. So therefore had to be careful. Nowadays business law had also been implement for the benefit of protecting business.

    Full disclosure of the business will be the best, because another business can see the full potential of investing in the business/merge with the business.

    Even in management strategy, why some company decide to take over or buy over another company knowing it's going to collapse? Because they can see the potential of growth in establish or merging with another company. And network actually play the most important part..Because it's connect business to business via communication and build up strong relations.
  • NDA or no NDA, tailoring your value-proposition should include heavy components of the individuals talent.

    Ideas a a dime a dozen. Thought leadership, and execution ability are the CRITICAL components.

    If you have the $$, a patent is the way to go. Work with friendly angels first.

    Unfortunately the "Angels" in Singapore are all SHARKS in disguise with ZERO idea of the value they represent.
  • BL
    Prashant,

    Yes, this is the same in Singapore, for the investors from the US (at least for those who I know) or people who are trained there. Some Asian investors are okay if you ask whether they can sign an NDA. In Europe, the situation is in the reverse. If you don't bring a NDA, it demonstrate that you know nothing about protecting your own intellectual property.
  • Hi,
    I am currently in Silicon Valley and I attend many seminars and conferences related to venture capital, entrepreneurship, etc.
    And one thing that VCs keep reminding us at these events is to NOT take an NDA to a VC. They say that it is the easiest way to lose the opportunity of getting that investor to invest.
    One of them actually mentioned that he/she doesn't even grant the first meeting to those who mention NDAs in their emails to the VC.
    I know it's kinda stupid to release your idea without getting an NDA signed, but from what I have seen, there isn't really another option when it comes to approaching VCs.
    Bernard, have you heard of this as well? Is this commonplace in Singapore too?

    Prashant.
blog comments powered by Disqus