The Dark Side of Young Entrepreneurial Students

July 14, 2006 by Bernard Leong  
Filed under Entrepreneurial Mindset

Most young entrepreneurial students possess common weaknesses which made them very difficult to be mentored by successful and older entrepreneurs. They easily succumb to the dark side because of their desire for personal success and gain, rather than thinking that the organization is bigger than themselves. Here is a breakdown of these features lacking in them.

Two days back, over a supper with Justin and an older and distinguished entrepreneur, we discussed about the importance of finding good and talented people. Both the older entrepreneur and I agreed that the best enterprises are determined not by their ideas or cash, but by the team who found the startup. Both the entrepreneur and I believe that moulding young people into successful entrepreneurs is far simpler than trying to convert someone who is around our age and has no experience in entrepreneurship. While I have spent some time discussing the dilemma of young entrepreneurial students, this article will talk about the dark side of young entrepreneurial students. I don’t classify someone as an entrepreneur unless he or she has formally started a company or social/non-profit enterprise. I refer to this group of people to be between 18 to 30 and most of them are studying in the tertiary institutions.

Here is a break down of common poor features which both the older entrepreneur and I see in young entrepreneurial students.

    1. Lack of Focus: When a student wants to work on a business idea, he or she needs to see it through. Most young people tend to jump ship too quickly or overload themselves with too many projects. Most successful entrepreneurs are focussed on one thing, their idea/startup/product and nothing else. Here is the advice: focus and make one successful startup, and once that happened, you can multi-task to make all the other appealing ideas work because you will have the credibility and attract people to work with you.
    2. Lack of Loyalty: Contrary to what most people see in American corporate culture that everything is cut-throat and destroying each other, loyalty is an important attribute that most successful entrepreneurs have. As a matter of fact, successful entrepreneurs will grow those who are loyal compare to those who jump ship too early. Most young entrepreneurs don’t believe in that. Of course, there are two sides of the coin. Some senior people does not want to groom the younger people and led them to jump ship. In those cases, I can understand the frustration of the young people. How about those who are helping the young to grow? The process of teaching an entrepreneur is long and tedious and takes some time. These are the kind of students which will fail the credibility test. If the student is lack of loyalty, he or she will definitely lack consistency. That inconsistency will lead to lack of quality and that lack of quality will lead to them losing credibility.
    3. Lack of Knowledge: Almost 95% of the students I met in Singapore has very little knowledge about the industry or how the markets move. That’s why you find them crowding among themselves in a networking event. It means that they have nothing to talk to the industry people or the people who might be able to help them in the future. They find that reading good books and periodicals are a chore. Here is the secret why most Cambridge students manage to secure good jobs for themselves and it has been taught by the careers centre. Before you enter into the networking event hosted by that company (be it an investment bank, management consultancy or etc), one of the items on the checklist is to read the Financial Times (yesterday and today), Harvard Business Review, the Wall Street Journal and the Economist. If you cannot impress the people who are here to recruit you with the knowledge and understanding you have, what makes you think that you can start a company? I often hear students telling me about the industries they want to go into and the moment I ask them which the top 5 companies in that area and their competitors, they cannot answer me.
    4. Lack of Quality and Professionalism: I cannot fault students for this, but the problem is that they don’t learn from their mistakes. That is when quality steps in. If you see the person repeating the same mistake over and over again, you can just fire the person.
    5. Lack of Speed : Speed is the major problem in most young people I see in Singapore. If you are really passionate about what you do, you will spend time beyond your work to do it. After all, if you are an entrepreneur, what you are doing should be fun. The same fun must also translate to your team. I find that most young students have this tendency of procrastinate and let opportunities slip by. The standard of young entrepreneurs that I have seen in Boston and Cambridge, can engage quickly and also produce quality work. This is something I find lacking in the student team. There is no sense of imperative action. For a startup, to beat your competitors is more than about cash, but your speed to innovate and finding ways to block your competitors from capturing your markets. Someone from INSEAD interviewed me recently and he asked me what the successful factors in making SimuGen happen. I told him that it was speed. At that point, I was racing against time to ensure that the startup is in good shape before I leave UK. The team has literally less than 3 hours of sleep per day to ensure that everything is right for the presentation and the business plan. We actually check out each other’s scope and offer assistance when necessary. All we want to see is that our message gets out and tell ourselves that we cannot afford to procrastinate.

Most young entrepreneurial students need to realize that good mentors look for certain features in a person and grow them into successful individuals. It is a hard and ardous journey for a young entrepreneur. If you cannot bear the starting from bottom down to ground up, then I can safely say that you are not suitable to be an entrepreneur.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Posterous
  • Tumblr
  • del.icio.us
  • LinkedIn
  • Mixx
  • Technorati
  • email

No related posts.


Comments

  • Steveocs
    Hei all, it is encouraging to note that many of the veterans here are more than willing to share with the young entrepreneurs. Being soon-to-grad NUS students I must say I have learned a thing or two from the discussion here.:)

    At least I will have some ideas on setting up my mindset to the correct path to be an entrepreneur.:)

    Thanks again for all the insight, particularly BL. Appreciate it~
  • BL great write up. Echos what we talked about the other day.

    One thing about mentorship and aspiring young people, i suggest to leave it to the young people to look for the mentors. I'm a strong supporter of giving help when help is asked and needed. I've left comments to myself most of the time.
  • Anonymous
    Sorry I would like to requote the phrase up there, "If nobody ever made a mistake then in reality they haven't yet learn anything."

    And seriously, I believe the older generations should give their great insights to other veteran or greenhorn.

    Just like my professor, an entrepreneur, He is a great inventor of more than 100 products which is currently patented within the market. But he is not a selfish man. He is willing to share his knowledge with others.

    So I really look forward to see the older generation enpassing their skills to the younger generation to help them to learn and of course to continue to sustain their credibility towards another extended level.

    It's not just about the American dream but helping others fulfilling their dreams as well. ;)
  • Anonymous
    IMHO, I think the older generation should slowly mentor the younger generation. Though, I can see many young entrepreneur are still learning. But if nobody give them a chance. How can they ever learn or excel?
    Though they are still green horn. But just give them a chance.

    I have seen many disrespectful younger generations who that words for granted and really think the whole world earn them everything. But imagine that when you first started your own business. There are also alot of trials and tribulations that you had been through. I believe there are hard and difficult times when you wish for an opportunity to be granted to you.

    And this goes to the veteran/greenhorn nowadays. Often not alot of people would like to enpass all their knowledge to the next generation. So what can the younger generation? They only can make mistake. Hence learn from their own mistake. That's how I gone through..

    Who was never a green horn before? Who never wish someone could lend a helping hand to them? However, I believe the older generation can mentor the younger generation through different methods by sharing their experience.

    And the younger generations who close their ear and stick to their own way then let them be. Seriously, nobody can help them if they do not want to listen. The older generation just do their best and younger generation are the ones who should be choosing whether to listen or not listen. Laws or imperial order should not be enforced to them. It's just like tie them down and suffocating them without enabling them to think. Young entrepreneurs today should be independant. They should learn as much from studying as well as trying to be innovative.

    Look at the kids overseas. I can tell you they are way better and much luckier than the kids in Singapore because they eventually breed kids at younger age of 8yrs old to 12yrs old to invent new products and of course the kids are more innovative that the older generation can imagine. But because the older generation actually support the younger kids to invent. They invent all sorts of things and was encourage by the government as well as having their goods patent in the market. Though they don't have the engineering ideas but they had specialist from different area to co-operate with them to help them successfully invent a product and this is what the society want. A team that work together and can harmonize together inorder to achieve sound productive achievement. The kids are all greenhorns. But seriously, babies don't just learn to crawl when they are new born. They need the adult to help them and support them. I believe all of us had been babies before that come out from our mother's womb. And I seriously think instead of just critizing them. We should actually help them or provide them with adequate feedback.

    And also has anybody who started out never made a mistake? I found one very interesting phrase in the company that I work for. If nobody ever made a mistake then in reality they are not learning.

    Your mind needs to open like a parachute to show that it's working. ;)
  • Dear Kee Peow,

    I fully understand that the dynasty of "imperial edicts" are over & the younger generation are free to question their seniors.

    While I am ready to let the youngsters give me feedback, the METHOD which they do it sounds as if the whole world owes them the answer. Youngsters of this generation are now better informed in this Information Age but that doesn't mean they can talk back in a defiant manner. They must remember that although they might be current with information, all these are only theories. People like me weather all kind of real life battle experience. How can a scholar general who never fought a war in his lifetime ever question a veteran general like Norman Schwarzkopf in a defiant manner?

    Remember the CNA interview with MM Lee Kuan Yew engaging a young audience? That's the classic example of how "capable" our youngsters are. They are totally clueless about engaging a veteran figure like Lee Kuan Yew. I can see that LKY is very willing to share his views & insights but the ATTITUDE of the youngsters really put him off. They shoot questions off their mouths without consideration of the situation. In SAF, we called it "SA" or situation awareness.

    I encourage youngsters to engage their mentors in the correct way. Many mentors are willing to share if they are approached correctly in whatever discipline, entrepreneurship or not.
  • Kee Peow
    A very good article, BL.

    Ramcem, it is good that you are taking time to mentor the next generation of entrepreneurs. One point to note though, is that times have changed and perhaps treating the coach's instructions as "imperial edicts" may be not for our time. Many a time in business, we need to be bold enough to question "why is the market/people doing things this way? Any ways we can do it better than them?" To foster this kind of mentality in our business folks, they have to have an enquiring and very very independent mind that think through instructions, words, advice, books, etc that they come into contact. Nevertheless, I believe that it is important to question with tact and respect for others. Wisdom can come from many ways, and learning to disagree is important.

    To add on to Claris' point, I am happy to see that many funding, mentorship, entrepreneurial venture schemes here have quite a few hurdles to pass through before handing out the good stuff. These hurdles can incl, interviews, biz plan presentation, experience, good teamwork, multiple reviews by various agencies/committees, etc. It would take a tough and patient businessman to get through all these I feel and to some point, a few of them have mentioned that these hurdles can have the possible effect of defeating the help that was intended in the first place. I guess good things come to those who wait.
  • and few are chosen to be entrepreneur because only they themselve can choose to be entrepreneur, no one else can.
  • Hi,
    I couldn't agree with you more. What you said is pretty true of today's youngster who born to witness the internet hype and myth. Most still believe in the Yahoo and Google's dream and most will believe MORE business is more $$$$.

    What ppl today lacking is true passion together with commitment. Most just want to get rich by working hard and then intend to sell off the company. Often that kind of thought could not sustain them when real trial comes. Most will sell off their project when they yet to harness their product's potential, and most project probably never seen end of day in another's company's hand.


    "When the going get tough, the tough get going". Yes, one have to be tough to become entrepreneur, but often it is the determination to fulfil own's vision to create a product/service that unique and serve customer first rather than monetary desire that keep one going trial after trial. Nothing can take the joy of seeing the customer used the product and benefit from it.


    In fact, the best way to train the student is to encourage the student to do something on their own, and independently, to let them feel the pain and struggle of achieving what they want, without having a mentor first. These student have to be self-reliant and reflective of their own action. It only with these thought can they seriously think of what they really want in their life, and sacrifice time, effort and money to achieve them. Giving them too much resource to assist them gives them the thought that they are lucky, smart and intelligent which in fact is not. Most often, these will only make them take thing for granted. This also make them realize that entrepreneur is never a bed of roses. It is fact full of thorn. It is only when you get use to the pain that the thorn has no effect. And it is through great pain and struggle can you really achieve great thing. Forget about what other preach you to say "If you love your job, it is not a job" . If you are doing something great, it is really just pain and struggle because you need discipline and focus, and these two often means you may not always get to do things you like in your venture.


    Only when hardship and understanding come, can they find meaning in their passion and commitment. If what they developed is not their "baby", perhaps it was never a passion in the first place.


    We shouldn't live in america dream where the press will want you to believe it's all easy money. In fact, it is not, those people who the another company really buy over their product has actually struggle hard for few years and obtain the expertise, knowledge and skill to create innovative product.
    Read the true story of "Writely" the AJAX word processor that is acquired by Google.
    http://earlystagevc.typepad.com/earlystagevc/20...
    The press will want you to believe that these people is lucky. But without skill, expertise and knowledge and potential to do great thing, how lucky can you be ? Maybe, one can be lucky to get interview to work in Google, but then get reject after screening because of lack of experience and skill.


    So, this story tell us that we should focus on doing what we do best to innovate product and forget the "hype" that we can diversified into many "money-making product" and come out as winner. In other words, LESS business is more $$$$.

    There always bound to be some who become rich by diversifying into many product area, but then, we ask yourselves, do we really want to bet on it ??? Sometimes, it just more than meet the eyes to find out why that somebody succeed etc connection, reputation, wealthy family and investor.

    and yes, do dream big but start everything small.
  • This article is indeed close to my heart & experience. Most youngsters whom I coached these few years think that they are so smart that the whole world owes them a living. They argue back on lots of my instructions to them.

    Contrast it when I was learning from my mentor when I first started out, his instructions to us are like imperial edicts. Sometimes I do feel strange by the instructions but nevertheless will strive my best to fulfil his orders. Later when the dust settle do I see his wisdom. I would be a fool and learned nothing if I argue back.

    In a nutshell, Singapore youths have a lot to catch up compared with their more hungry overseas counterparts.

    ~Ramcem
blog comments powered by Disqus